Church Systems Task Force Report on Clergy Health

published on Monday, June 13, 2011 by jbjames@duke.edu

A few days ago, the United Methodist News Service published a story about clergy health.  The story is tied to a task force report that the UMC’s General Board of Pension and Health Benefits (GBPHB) and the General Board of Higher Education and Ministry (GBHEM) released in May.  To address the challenges pastors face to their health and wellness, the Church Systems Task Force proposes some recommended actions to present at General Conference in 2012.

Though their analysis was conducted independently, it seems that the Church Systems Task Force came to conclusions that are compatible with the Clergy Health Initiative’s: that from the local church to the policy-making boards, all parts of the church have a duty and a stake in improving clergy health.  I especially appreciated the name "Church Systems," as it seems to me to reflect the Clergy Health Initiative’s practice of thinking about health holistically and ecologically, across all layers of the church.  We know that it is an oversimplification to say that pastors are unhealthy and need to be fixed, or worse, need to fix themselves.  Declines in clergy health may be most readily observed in rising health insurance costs, and in the form of excess body weight and its attendant chronic physical problems, but the causes run much deeper.  Rather, we should work upstream, examining the (sometimes implicit) demands that the denomination places on its worship leaders across the continuum of ministry and find ways to reduce these pressures, which can negatively impact health. 

In that vein, the task force’s five major recommendations are:

  • More help for those entering licensed or ordained ministry
  • Guidelines for healthy work/life balance
  • Changes to itinerancy and appointment-making
  • A redefinition of the district superintendent's role
  • Help for those exiting ordained ministry


"God is in the details," the saying goes, and I’m sure we’ll have more to say about the report’s contents in coming months.  But one statement I note with interest is that the district superintendent is envisioned in a coaching role that includes embodying clergy wellness.  That alone sounds like a big change indeed!  I think the DS’s would be the first to say that they’re not always exemplars of sound work-life balance. 

We’d love to hear your thoughts on the report.

Blessings on the work of the Western North Carolina Annual Conference, who’ve just returned from Lake Junaluska, and to the North Carolina Annual Conference that gets underway in Raleigh this Wednesday.

Shalom y'all,

John

John James, M.A.
Research Analyst, Clergy Health Initiative

0 comments | Add a comment

A votre santé! (To your health!)

published on Monday, June 6, 2011 by jbjames@duke.edu

Could our diet be a symptom, rather than a cause, of our unhealthy and unbalanced lives? 

For many years, citizens of countries such as Greece, Italy, and Yugoslavia enjoyed excellent health relative to the rest of the world.  Public health researchers credited the "Mediterranean Diet," an assemblage of foods that features fruits, vegetables, fish and poultry, whole grains, and olive oil (and includes little red meat or processed food). 

But it wasn’t just the nutrients in these foods that imparted well-being – healthful eating in Mediterranean cultures was defined by positive social values.  The food economy was small-scale and local; no one was far removed from the people whose physical labor produced the food on their tables.  The people also prioritized the preparation and slow consumption of food in the hierarchy of their daily demands, cultivating a time of sharing and personal interaction.  Time spent eating was relaxing, nourishing to the spirit, and pleasant to the senses. 

But recent studies indicate that the health advantage of people in southern Europe is slipping away.  The Mediterranean diet is changing, and so is the Mediterranean lifestyle.  Patterns of production and consumption are becoming more globalized.  Fast food chains have arrived in countries like Greece for the first time.  Fewer people are in jobs that are physically involving.

Sounds like America, doesn’t it? 

In our conversations with clergy, we’ve heard again and again how the demands of the job make it difficult to eat healthfully or exercise.  So we elected to add a mindful eating component called Naturally Slim® to our wellness program, Spirited Life; many of our participants are going through it now and sharing with us that already they’re enjoying remarkable success.  Naturally Slim’s lessons call attention to our culture’s tendency to make food choices based on convenience, rather than rooting them in our values or faith commitments, and provides ways to change that habit.  It’s an initial step toward moving pastors into a frame of mind that approximates what people in Mediterranean cultures have known for centuries.

I was alerted to the Mediterranean Diet article by Pastor Mary Frances McClure and the website of Trinity UMC in Red Springs (North Carolina Conference, Rockingham District).  Mary Frances discusses how the congregation might multiply table fellowship with one another, and extend hospitality to community members who habitually eat alone.  Her post is well worth reading.

Stay cool out there.


John James, M.A.
Research Analyst, Clergy Health Initiative

0 comments | Add a comment

A Prayer for Health

published on Tuesday, May 31, 2011 by kjm20@duke.edu

It seems that prayer for good health is on the rise.  New research, published in May in the journal Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, notes that in a comparison of two studies, 49 percent of respondents actively prayed for their own good health in 2007, up from 43 percent in 2002. 

What I found interesting is the fact that the individuals who pray for their well-being are also the most likely to take steps to protect their health by doing things like regularly seeing a physician.  That gives me hope that rather than sending up an empty “wish” for God to take care of them (despite what they may do to strain their minds and bodies), these individuals are seeking strength through God.  And that through God’s grace, they’ll find the means to take positive action in their own lives. 

It’s something to pray for, anyway.

Kate Rugani
Communications Director
Duke Clergy Health Initiative

0 comments | Add a comment

Pages